Removing Road Blocks to Housing Finance: New Findings from Latin America

Print
 
Mar 2012
Washington DC, USA, March, 06 2012 - Can we possibly address financial inclusion without discussing housing microfinance? Financing for housing is in great demand, frequently cited as clients’ top choice after a business loan, and is the most commonly identified utilization of business financing outside of financing businesses.

MFIs consistently report that housing portfolios perform as well as or better than other loan products, and believe that it balances portfolio risk and increases profitability (even though concrete data is often lacking).

Housing microfinance typically refers to non-mortgage housing loans utilized primarily for home improvements, repairs, and incremental building. Loan terms are generally under three years, and interest rates tend to be within the market range for microfinance loans. For the majority of the world’s poor, who build homes incrementally as financing becomes available, housing microfinance is uniquely tailored to match their building and financing patterns. Moreover, improved housing contributes to social benefits of improved health, education, economic stability and security. So why is it that housing microfinance isn’t growing faster, given the compelling advantages to both financial institutions and the clients they serve?

Habitat for Humanity’s Center for Innovation in Shelter and Finance recently undertook a study to determine the status of housing microfinance in Latin America, seeking to identify key factors facilitating or restricting its growth. Thirteen retail financial institutions and five second-tier institutions, providing technical assistance and funding to MFIs in Latin America, participated via phone interview or survey. Building on an earlier study conducted jointly with ACCION International in 2006, the recent report revealed that limitations to growth in housing microfinance continue to be supply-driven. More specifically, MFIs in Latin America are frequently reluctant to allow housing to assume an increased share of their overall portfolios, lest this lead them away from their traditional mission of supporting enterprise development and income generation. Furthermore, MFIs tend to restrict housing microfinance to their existing clientele, as a type of reward or incentive to increase client retention. This restriction results in a strategy of limited growth potential given that borrowers’ debt capacity is already partially compromised with a business loan. Very few of the MFIs surveyed were extending housing loans to other legitimate market sectors, such as low-income salaried workers, wage earners, remittance recipients and pensioned retirees.

Other findings from the study include:

  • Ensuring that clients invest their loans in housing is cited as one of the key challenges to implementing housing microfinance successfully, so as to distinguish the product from a consumer loan and minimize its cannibalization of other loan products.
  • Providing technical assistance in construction to clients remains on the frontier of housing microfinance as successful, scalable models are yet to be proven; nevertheless, approximately half of the institutions interviewed are engaged in partnerships assisting them in testing the delivery of these non-financial services.
  • Welcoming alternative actors within the housing microfinance space will be increasingly critical. Significant non-traditional suppliers of housing microfinance have emerged from among corporations capitalizing on the vast opportunities at the base of the pyramid. Possibly the best known example is CEMEX’s Patrimonio Hoy, which reports having reached over 300,000 Mexican families since its inception in 1998. Patrimonio Hoy employs a savings-first strategy to provide low-income families with access to building materials at competitive prices as well as microfinance and technical advice.

The coming decade should see a dramatic increase in housing microfinance as a diverse array of providers is attracted to a financial service that’s good for business and good for clients.



 

Research Analysis Tools

The fund indexes, institution benchmarks and other market information displayed here are all Symbiotics designed analysis tools, created in-house by our analysts and experts. Symbiotics has one of the oldest track records in microfinance investment analysis dating back to the late 1990s; its indexes and benchmarks have been regularly used as markers by investors, asset managers, financial institutions and practitioners. These, as well as several other research products, are available through the Research Account. Click on the link below to find out more.

Learn More